Bill Clinton

Testimony before the Starr Grand Jury (1998)

Tape Four - Questions from Grand Jurors:

Q: If Monica Lewinsky has stated that her affidavit that she didn't have a sexual relationship with you is, in fact, a lie, I take it you disagree with that?

PRESIDENT CLINTON: No. I told you before what I thought the issue was there, I think the issue is how do you define sexual relationship. And there was no definition imposed on her at the time she executed the affidavit. Therefore, she was free to give it any reasonable meaning.

Q: And if she says she was lying

PRESIDENT CLINTON: And I believe

Q: under your common sense ordinary meaning that you talked about earlier, Mr. President, that most Americans would have, if she says sexual relationship, saying I didn't have one was a lie because I had oral sex with the President, I take it, you would disagree with that?

PRESIDENT CLINTON: Now, we're back to where we started and I have to invoke my statement. But, let me just say one thing. I've read a lot, and obviously I don't know whether any of it's accurate, about what she said, and what purports to be on those tapes.

And this thing and I searched my own memory. This reminds me, to some extent, of the hearings when Clarence Thomas and Anita Hill were both testifying under oath. Now, in some rational way, they could not have both been telling the truth, since they had directly different accounts of a shared set of facts. Fortunately, or maybe you think unfortunately, there was no special prosecutor to try to go after one or the other of them, to take sides and try to prove one was a liar. And so, Judge Thomas was able to go on and serve on the Supreme Court

What I learned from that, I can tell you that I was a citizen out there just listening. And when I heard both of them testify, what I believed after it was over, I believed that they both thought they were telling the truth.

This is you're dealing with, in some ways, the most mysterious area of human life. I'm doing the best I can to give you honest answers.

Q: Mr. President

PRESIDENT CLINTON: And that's all I can say.

Q: I'm sorry.

PRESIDENT CLINTON: And, you know, those people both testified under oath. So, if there'd been a special prosecutor, they could, one of them could have gone after Anita Hill, another could have gone after Clarence Thomas. I thank God there was no such thing then, because I don't believe that it was a proper thing.

Q: One of

PRESIDENT CLINTON: And I think they both thought they were telling the truth. So, maybe Ms. Lewinsky believes she's telling the truth, and I'm glad she got her mother and herself out of trouble. I'm glad you gave her that sweeping immunity. I'm glad for the whole thing. I, I, I it breaks my heart that she was ever involved in this.

 

Return to Main Page

Boston.com

Documents reveal depth of Lewinsky's feelings for Clinton

By Ron Fournier, Associated Press, 09/21/98

 
This photo from page 2993 of Kenneth Starr's report on President Clinton shows Monica Lewinsky's blue coctail dress and gifts given to her by the President.
------------------------------

Value of Lewinsky's gifts

Dollar value of the gifts exchanged by Monica Lewinsky and President Clinton, as estimated by Richard F. Driscoll, an antique appraiser in Washington:

Sterling silver tabletop cigarette or cigar holder given to Clinton, $65.

 

  • Hatpin given to Ms. Lewinsky, $3.

     

  • Gold brooch given to Ms. Lewinsky, $5.

     

  • Blanket depicting Radio City Music Hall's Rockettes given to Ms. Lewinsky, $50.

     

  • Grizzly bear sculpture given to Ms. Lewinsky, $200.

     

  • Antique paperweight in the shape of the White House given to Clinton, $10.

    - BY ASSOCIATED PRESS, 09/21/98

WASHINGTON - Monica Lewinsky considered President Clinton ''my sexual soulmate'' until long periods of inattention made it painfully clear that their relationship would not last. ''I feel disposable, used and insignificant,'' she said in a handwritten note to the president.

Asked by grand jurors on Aug. 20 to describe their relationship, Ms. Lewinsky said, ''More love, with a little bit of obsession, but definitely love.''

Hundreds of pages of documents released by Congress today reveal the depth of Ms. Lewinsky's feelings for Clinton, a married man more than twice her age.

''She's basically a good girl,'' Clinton told grand jurors in testimony released today. But he complained that she ''felt the need to cling'' when he tried to break the relationship off.

The mountains of paperwork unveiled today shows that even before Ms. Lewinsky began cooperating with Kenneth Starr, she provided prosecutors with a roadmap of the relationship.

Ms. Lewinsky circled dates in her pocket calendar every time she met or talked to Clinton. Her home computer's memory was filled with letters - some never sent - to the president and her friends. By the time she first testified, prosecutors had compiled for grand jurors a lengthy chart detailing the affair.

She called it ''the highlights of my relationship with the president.''

The chart outlined the affair with shorthand notations, such as ''non-verbal connection'' on Aug. 9, 1995 and ''pizza night'' Nov. 17, 1995.

''I knew I was in love with him ... and I thought he cared about me,'' she testified.

''Bill, I love you with all my heart,'' she wrote in 1997.

''Please be nice to me ... Please be my friend,'' she wrote Nov. 12, 1997, pleading for him to let them get together.

''I've always felt that he was sort of my sexual soulmate,'' she testified.

Again and again it's the same: ''You looked gorgeous ... simply delicious ... I'm tired of crying ... I love you ... ''

Asked if Clinton ever asked her to deny their affair, she said that wasn't necessary. ''I would always protect him.''

When the former White House intern finally realized the affair was over, she grew bitter. Underlining every word, she wrote to Clinton in June 1997, ''Please do not do this to me. I feel disposable, used and insignificant.''

''I believe the time has finally come for me to throw in the towel,'' she said in another note found on her computer. ''I give up. You let me down, but I shouldn't have trusted you in the first place.''

Following his Aug. 17 address to the nation confessing the affair, Ms. Lewinsky told grand jurors that Clinton seemed to dismiss their relations as a ''service contract.''

Among her more interesting observations, Ms. Lewinsky said:

They didn't have sex in the Oval Office itself because ''it wouldn't be appropriate, you know.''

Video Archive from ABC News

APOLOGIES
Real Audio
September 3, 1998
During a photo session with the Irish prime minister, Clinton said "he's very sorry" regarding Monica Lewinsky.

Real Video

August 17, 1998
President Clinton admits publicly to having a relationship with former White House intern Monica Lewinsky that was "not appropriate."

Real Video

HIGHLIGHTS
January 21, 1998
Clinton denies allegations on The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer.

Real Video
January 26, 1998
On the eve of his State of the Union address, President Clinton once again denies having an affair with Lewinsky.

Real Video
January 28, 1998
First lady Hillary Clinton denies allegations of Clinton's affair with Lewinsky on ABCNEWS' Good Morning America.

Real Audio
July 31, 1998
"No one wants to get this matter behind us more than I do."

Real Video
May 1996
President Clinton and Monica Lewinsky at a fundraising event.

Real Video
October 1996
President Clinton and Monica Lewinsky after his speech at the Sheraton Washington Hotel.

Real Video
November 6, 1996
Monica Lewinsky embraces President Clinton as he greeted well-wishers at a White House lawn party.

Real Video

Clinton video testimony in full

President Clinton's video-taped testimony on the Monica Lewinsky affair has now been released for publication by the House Judiciary Committee.
August 17, 1998

[ image:  ]
Select a link below for the complete four hours of testimony.

Tape 1    Tape 2     Tape 3    Tape 4    Tape 5    Tape 6    Tape 7