44.312 Security Management

home page > Unit 10: Labor Relations

Topics:

History of private security's relationship to organized labor
Current union situation
Successful unions
Organizing strategies
Bargaining relationship
Security guards's representation rights under the NLRA
Collective bargaining
Strikes
Dispute resolution
Security in an organized labor setting
(based on. Ch. 10, Principles of Security Management)


Unions, under the NLRB Act, are defined as "any organization of any kind where employees participate, which exists for whole or in part in dealing with employers involving grievances, labor disputes, pay, hours of employment and working conditions."

History of private security's relationship to organized labor
private security firms particularly distrusted because management has frequently used them in anti-union activities, including some particularly violent strike-breaking efforts such as the Pinkertons' use in the Homestead Strike against Carnegie Steel, the contract guards in the Colorado Coal Wars, Harry Bennett's violent "Battle of the Overpass" against the UAW, etc.


Current union situation
In general, the labor movement has been declining since its high of 34.7% of the labor force in 1954 -- down to 12.9% of the work force in 2003 in large part due to global economy and loss of manufacturing jobs, free trade treaties such as NAFTA, the shift in US to a service-based economy, passage of federal work protections such as anti-discrimination and minimum wage laws. Also, the public isn't as supportive, for example, crossing picket lines.

They typically work to protect workers' collective rights -- not an individual worker's individual rights of an employee, and to limit employers' powers. Their power comes from:

  • ability to exercise nonpolitical power, such as a strike against an employer
  • achieving collective good through collective voice: represent workers' concerns to employers
  • secure collective goods in exchange for ensuring workers' cooperation and productivity
  • can purchase collective goods for its members by trading off lesser benefits, ie., a wage increase instead of a no-layoff clause

I believe the International Guards Union of America is the only one that only serves guards. Some guards are members of the SEIU.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6